by Tom Kando
I’m sick and tired of hearing how very unpopular “liberal” has become in America.
I’m sick and tired of America’s extreme rightward drift. Don’t be mistaken about it: We are THE most conservative country in the world today!
I am sick and tired of the cliché “we are the richest country in the world.” I can think of a dozen countries that are richer (see List of Countries).
And as to the distribution of wealth, well in that regard we are doing worse than nearly ALL other developed countries. Our still relatively high per capita income obfuscates the fact that we have more obscenely rich and also more devastating poverty than most other western nations. Among OECD countries (the 35 largely more developed countries of the world), the US has the fourth highest Gini coefficient of inequality, after Mexico, Chile and Turkey! We are in good company! (See Inequality) Our relative income poverty is nearly 17%, the third highest among these 35 countries. And with the new Republican tax package, things are about to get a lot worse.
I am sick and tired of seeing America self-destruct, of seeing a once promising country going to hell.
I am sick and tired of seeing it all fall apart - the infrastructure, the schools, the health care system, housing, the environment, research.
I am sick and tired of hearing that the government does everything inefficiently and that private business does everything better. There is no evidence for this faddish falsehood.
I am sick and tired of equivocation, of debating the issues from “both sides,” of being “open-minded.”
I feel that I have done my homework. I have a PhD in Sociology, I have read thousands of books, I still turn on Fox News and pick up the Wall Street Journal sometimes, so I DO see it “from both sides.”
But by and large, my mind is made up. I have clarity. I don’t need to rehash the “left-right” conversation. So here are my conclusions:
1. There are two categories of people: Liberals and idiots.
2. Liberals are right because they favor equality, justice, mutual help, cooperation and love. Conservatives are wrong because they accept injustice, advocate competition, favor selfishness and greed.
3. Liberals are right because their policies work. The countries with the best quality of life and the greatest human happiness are all liberal. Check out Scandinavia, Australia, Canada and a host of other highly successful countries.
4. Taxes are too low. They should be raised, especially on the richest.
5. Profits should be taxed more than labor. Employers/businessmen should be taxed more than employees. Investments and inheritance should be taxed more than work. For example, when a physician and an employer or an investor earn the same amount, the physician should be taxed less than the other two individuals.
6. Health insurance should be universal and mandatory, just like car insurance for anyone who drives. It can be single-payer and government-run. Medicare for everyone, pure and simple. Ideally, health insurance companies would cease to exist. Or else, it could be a heavily regulated for-profit system.
7. Bullet trains should be built and other forms of mass transit should be funded to the max.
8. We should consider making airlines, airports, railroads and other transportation services into public utilities, just as most of our urban subway and bus systems already are, thank goodness. Amtrak is a hybrid - publicly funded, but for-profit. It is not clear that it works better than the magnificent French SNCF, which is fully government owned.
9. Cap and trade policies to protect the environment should be maximized.
10. The private sector is every bit as inefficient and bureaucratic as the government. Are Amazon, UPS and Fed Ex more efficient than the US Postal Service? Are your private healthcare provider and insurance company more responsive than Medicare? Do Comcast, Apple, Macy's, United Airlines and Intel provide faster and better technical support and other service than Social Security? When you go to the Apple store with a problem, you have to make an appointment for two weeks later before you can even explain what your problem is! With most businesses, you are lucky if you get to talk to someone in New Delhi, Manila, or CostaRica. Companies such as Twitter (San Francisco) can’t even be reached by telephone, period!
If you get the impression that I am a socialist, it is because I am. I am a liberal and a socialist, and proud of it.
P.S.
A brief clarification for our European readers: In Europe, “liberal” is still often used in the sense of “classical liberal,” which refers to right-of-center, pro-business, conservative political parties such as the VVD in the Netherlands. In the US. the term has long had an opposite meaning, namely “left,” “progressive,” etc. I use the word in the American sense. I hope that this is not misunderstood.
© Tom Kando 2017;All Rights Reserved
leave comment here
13 comments:
Tom, Your "I am sick" lines indicate to me that you are reacting, rather than trying to solve problems. You are right that liberalism has been a positive force, but it has been a positive force when it is constructive--solves problems rather than complains.
For example, Denmark has lowered its corporate tax rate for the last several years, while keeping taxes progressive on the wealthy. That sounds like constructive thinking. Democrats in the US complain when corporate tax rates are lowered because they fail to understand that corporate tax rates are a tax on production, not a tax on wealth.
Trump's election was a reaction against some of these failures of Democratic policy to distinguish between production and wealth. So no we have two reactionary parties and no constructive policy.
What many people fail to realize is that creating a new party won't solve the problem either, because sound processes of governance--checks, and balances--have been evaded by processes that allow pork to enter behemoth bills. Many of these broken processes need to be fixed before liberalism can actually work in the U.S.
So while I agree with many of the points you lament, your lamentation seems reactionary--failing to see or acknowledge problems with liberalism in the US that destroyed justice for the middle classes. So while Trumpism is reactionary, a reaction against the reaction doesn't strike me as pointing the way to progress.
Tom, well said! It seems like a night mare...
Living I Tennessee, the best one can do is working in a non-partisan way on projects that benefit the community. Treading carefully, inch by inch...
Yvonne
I'm with you on this, Tom. These tend to be discouraging times. But if winter comes, etc., etc. I hope the Alabama election outcome is a sign of hope!
Here! Here! I'm on board. I'm glad you did it. Now, I don't have to.
I thank the supportive comments. Of course, sometimes it feels like I’m preaching to the choir.
...Not entirely, though.
Gordon is a good old friend whom I respect a great deal (PhD, widely published and all that).
That said, though, he and I often disagree. For instance, I reject the accusation of being merely a “reactor.” Even in this very brief post, I offer many specific policy recommendations.
Also, I don’t agree that liberals have dug their own grave and that the two existing parties are equally bad. Democrats may not be saints, but their level of corruption and selfishness pales in comparison with that of the Republicans. Sorry, Gordon, but the GOP has become really, really bad since the days of Eisenhower, Edward Brooke, Everett Dirksen, Nelson Rockefeller, the Henry Cabot Lodges and the many other decent and competent Republican politicians of the past (not to mention Lincoln).
As to the reduction of the corporate tax: There is simply no need for that because (1) most corporations in effect don’t pay the full 35%, what with all their deductions and loopholes. (2) corporate profits are currently staggeringly high, and yet there is no commensurate capital investment and “job creation” going on. Instead there is the lining of shareholders’ and executives’ pockets
It is a great summary of a tragical state of affair.
One New York neurologist complained that 90% of his clientele now are suffering from anxiety and depression due to Trump-effects...
Great work, thanks Tom!
100% right on.
Thanks for making my day Tom. Nothing sweeter than watching lefty hand-wringing. MAGA!
Right on, Tom. I share your dogma.
Beware of dogmas of any kind. Maybe there is a third way i.e. a believe in the center. The pendulum swings both ways and having some faith in the check and balances of our system, even if it is not a popular or exciting discussion point to-day, will pay off over time.
Regarding the last anonymous: Sure, a ("centrist") third way. No problem.
But my "third way" is democratic socialism, as proposed by Bernie Sanders for instance. The extremes are Soviet-style ultra-communism, which is/was an abomination, and plutocratic capitalism as currently practiced by the GOP, which is also a pathology.
And absent my first choice, I’ll support the Democratic party over the Republicans any day, corrupt and imperfect as the former may be.
I don’t agree with those who see our two major parties as Tweedledee and Tweedledum. One of them is considerably more corrupt and immoral than the other. Just look at how very differently the two have responded to the Me-Too movement (sexual harassment) and to fascism in Charlottesville, and how the Republicans are far more in the pockets of rich donors and contributors.
Happy days are here again
The skies above are clear again
Let us sing a song of cheer again
Happy days are here again
Altogether shout it now
There's no one who can doubt it now
So let's tell the world about it now
Happy days are here again
...
You make a good argument for your political beliefs, Tom. I enjoy reading your blogs.
Post a Comment
Please limit your comment to 300 words at the most!