What I do want to complain about is the attitude I have encountered around me. Sometimes I get teased about my bi-annual trips to my mother. There is the insinuation that I am a mama’s boy; that I am “hung up” on my mother; that a “real man” wouldn’t do all of this.
But
there are some people around me who find
my behavior suspicious. Some of them have hardly seen their aging parents, as those approach death. Sometimes this is
because they live thousands of miles apart - as we do. Sometimes
there has been very little
contact even though they live close to each other. Admittedly, an elderly
parent - a parent at any age,
actually - can be an immense pain. Sometimes,
the alienation is the parent’s fault.
But what I don’t understand is that some people frown on what I do. In fact, my devotion should be appreciated and seen as virtuous filial behavior. In fairness, many of my friends do see it that way. But as I said, there are also those who find what I do a bit ridiculous, a bit Freudian, a bit unhealthy. Imagine that!
The
other day, after a downtown concert with some
friends, we were walking back to our cars. A homeless man approached us, begging pathetically
for a small donation. He explicitly
stated, timidly, that he had no intention of bothering us, that he was
absolutely not armed, but please, could we spare a dime?
I
complied with his request without hesitation, pulling a dollar bill out my wallet. You should have heard my friends’
reaction! Tom you are a fool! You are endangering yourself and us! You should
never get out your wallet like that, in
front of a homeless person!
I
have many friends and relatives who NEVER give money to a beggar, out of
“principle.” Their usual rationalization is that the beggar will use that money
for drugs. Amazing hogwash!
Don’t
get me wrong. I am no saint. I am often cranky. If a beggar is pushy or
annoying, I won’t give him anything. Nor do I naively walk down dark alleys.
But what’s wrong with giving a dollar to a guy standing at a street corner with
a sign saying “Homeless and Hungry,” while you wait for the stoplight to turn green? Is the
guy/woman having fun, freezing in the
rain or in the snow for a few bucks?
When
I was a kid - and I was a very, very poor kid, sometimes bordering on homelessness - I got to most places by
hitch-hiking. Both in Europe until my 18th birthday and in America after that. Hitch-hiking was
common. People hitch-hiked, and people picked up hitch-hikers. Later, when I
was no longer very poor, I picked up hitch-hikers. But soon, most people
rationalized that it’s too
dangerous to pick up hitch-hikers and this mutual aid custom went by the
wayside.
What
have we become? leave comment here
10 comments:
I visit my Mother at least once a month. It is just an hour's drive, so I can't compare, but family is the basic unit of society.
I think a lot of the fear of picking up strangers and a decrease in giving can be correlated to media and government activities that tell us the world is not safe--so we will watch their news or pay more taxes for protection.
I like to help, but not enable. Its a blurry line to be sure. I'm often either too enabling or too callus. I give food or a sandwich when I can over money. How can you help when we no longer have any institutionalising of our mentally ill, so your at risk of enabling someone to self-medicate. Almost all homeless are mentally ill, when you were getting assistance from others back when those who are homeless would be in an institution.
Visiting your 100 year old Mom only twice a year borders cold-heartedness...
Associating a son's love for his mother with problems virility or image is simply sick.
I agree that some of us have become selfish, heartless, fearful people--but also some are giving, loving and still aware that the world is a beautiful and dangerous place at the same time.
I too remember hitchhiking and the kindness and reflective generousity of strangers. Those gentle days are probably gone, but there are other good things done today.
Tom,
I recall hitching between Providence and New Haven when I was at Yale, and no one thought it dangerous. But now I can't recall the last time I saw anyone thumbing a ride, Sad.
Peter Shattuck
Your life story is very fascinating I think that visiting your mother is very sweet and I am 100% for caring for parents this is so important and gender should not be an issue .If you were a woman people would praise
You for that quality . On another note hitchhiking sounds dangerous and picking up strangers sounds equally as dangerous our society has changed quite a bit when it comes to people's motivations and intentions however I do agree that being helpful to homeless people is a good thing showing compassion to others when they are in need is an act of kindness That I would risk any day Gail
Thank you all for your comments.
Csaba, your second sentence is right on - my point precisely.
As to the first part of your comment, do keep in mind that it is not easy to take two annual trips of over 12,000 miles every time, usually staying 3 to 4 weeks. Last year, I had to do this in a cast (broken arm). More than that I cannot do.
Gordon makes a very good point, which relates to the comments made by Unknown, by Carol, by Peter and by Gail:
it is true that things have changed and that urban conditions can often be dangerous. However, the changed conditions cannot account for ALL of our changed attitudes. As a criminologist, I know crime statistics well. While there is more crime now than in the 1950s and early 60s, the crime rate has declined a great deal since the late 1980s. Therefore, some of our greater “callousness” must come from something else. We have become more “paranoid” (for want of a better term). Much of this has to do with the media’s and the politicians’ disproportionate focus on crime news.
Tom-
I suspect that some of your friends who cannot show compassion also believe that the government should take care of things. (As in Dickens - are their no prisons, are there no workhouses) Ultimately the mark of a good society is based on the compassion of the individuals in it.
My wife gets to her mother (who just turned 90) four or five times a year. (Albeit a much easier trip to Pasadena). There are hundreds of things that I would like to be able to ask my parents that I cannot - so treasure the time.
WELL SAID! Paradise is at the feet of Mothers.
I only have two things to say.
(1) I agree with what you are saying here.
(2) It is important to pick your friends carefully.
IMHO this is one of your better essays.
Post a Comment
Please limit your comment to 300 words at the most!