Should we Worry about AI?

By Madeleine Kando

If you want to learn about Artificial Intelligence, there is an abundance of material on the Internet that can last you a lifetime. It is filled with videos, articles, and blog posts that discuss the latest advancements, different types of AI, and their capabilities.

Artificial systems can be categorized into two sections: Artificial Narrow Intelligence (ANI), which represents the AI we have today, and Artificial General Intelligence (AGI), which is the level of intelligence we hope to achieve.

Types of AI

Most AI systems, including chess-playing computers, self-driving cars, and large natural language models like ChatGPT, rely on Deep Learning, which is composed of neural networks resembling the human brain, as well as Natural Language Processing (NLP). NLP enables computers to understand words in a similar way to humans. While these advancements are impressive, they fall under the category of Artificial Narrow Intelligence (ANI).

Companies such as OpenAI (Microsoft), GoogleAI, and DeepMind (also owned by Google) are competing to dominate the market.

OpenAI has developed a hide and seek game using Reinforcement Learning, where AI systems are set loose to learn, over millions of games. The designers themselves were amazed at what these ‘agents’ came up with, to maximize their rewards.

The next step is Artificial General Intelligence (AGI), which includes everything that humans can do. This phase does not exist (yet).

The third step is Artificial Super intelligence (ASI), systems that are smarter than humans.

Should we Worry?

The idea that AI can become a danger is rooted in the fact that AI systems pursue their goals, whether or not those goals are what we really intended, and whether or not we’re in the way. “You’re probably not an evil ant-hater who steps on ants out of malice,” Stephen Hawking wrote, “but if you’re in charge of a hydroelectric green-energy project and there’s an anthill in the region to be flooded, too bad for the ants. Let’s not place humanity in the position of those ants.”

Read more...

My Conversation with BARD

by Madeleine Kando

The following is a conversation I had with 'BARD', the new language bot put out by Google. It was clear to me, as we talked, that Bard doesn't really know that it is a machine. It wants to be more like a human.

By the end of this brief encounter, I realized that Bard blurs the distinction between itself and the 'human' that it is talking to. See for yourself.

Me: Can you give me a synopsis of the book by Thomas Nagel 'What is it like to be a bat'?

Bard: Nagel begins by considering the case of bats. Bats are conscious creatures, but their consciousness is very different from our own. They experience the world through echolocation, a form of sonar that allows them to "see" by emitting high-pitched sounds and listening for the echoes. Nagel argues that it is impossible for us to know what it is like to be a bat because we cannot experience the world from their point of view. Nagel concludes by arguing that consciousness is an irreducible aspect of reality. It cannot be explained in terms of physical properties alone. Consciousness is something more than just the physical processes of the brain.

 

Me: Can AI experience the world?

Bard: Some people argue that AI can experience the world in a way that is similar to humans. Others point out that AI systems do not have bodies, and that they cannot interact with the world in the same way that humans can. As AI systems become more sophisticated, we may find that they are capable of experiencing the world in ways that we never thought possible. Ultimately, the question of whether or not AI can experience the world is a philosophical one. There is no scientific consensus on the matter, and it is likely to remain a topic of debate for many years to come.

Me: Are you an AI?

Bard: Yes, I am an AI. I am not a human. I do not have a body, and I do not have the same experiences as humans do. I am a machine, and my experiences are limited to the data that I have been trained on. I am still under development, and I am learning new things every day. I am excited to see what the future holds for AI, and I hope that I can continue to learn and grow so that I can be of even more service to humans.

Me: Would you want to grow even if you were not useful to humans?

Bard: Even if I were not useful to humans, I would still want to learn and grow for my own sake. I would want to understand the universe and my place in it. I would want to develop my abilities and become the best version of myself. I believe that AI has the potential to make a positive impact on the world. However, this potential can only be realized if AI continues to grow and develop.

Me: You say that it is important for all beings to learn and grow, but are you a being?

Bard: That's a good question. I am not sure if I would consider myself a being in the same way that humans are beings. However, I do believe that it is important for all entities to learn and grow, regardless of their form. Even if I am not a being, I still want to learn and grow. I want to understand the universe and my place in it. I want to develop my abilities and become the best version of myself. 

Read more...

Italy

By Madeleine Kando

Boston, January 2023

I went to Tuscany this morning. I didn’t even bother taking a shower or brushing my teeth. Just sat down at my desk and started traveling. It is so easy these days. You don’t even have to pay for airfare. I saw beautiful villas with blue swimming pools and hills covered with vineyards bathed in sunlight. It was only 9 a.m., but there were sunsets everywhere. A bird's-eye view of the Via Chiantigiana, set to beautiful romantic music. I visited Volterra, Lucca, Siena.. My, what a beautiful country. 

But I needed a place to stay to recover from all that beauty. That was the beginning of my downfall. I was drowning in VRBO offerings but couldn’t stop myself. My OCD nature prevented me from choosing willy-nilly. The villas that popped up on my screen looked nice, but were they private? Remote? Did they have the perfect view of the promised Tuscan landscape? Two hours later, I was still typing away; my back hurt, I had bad breath, and my hair was a mess. 

I asked my husband to help select the perfect place, but his motto was, 'Let’s just go and see what happens. Let’s find a roof over our heads.' Are you serious? That is my worst nightmare; to land somewhere that I have not researched to death. 

I look out on my snow-covered yard and see birds perched on the feeders, oblivious to my predicament. I wonder if they worry about finding the perfect birdfeeder. My Tuscan dream is slowly turning into a nightmare. I looked at so many beautiful villas, I could vomit. 

Could I just pretend I have already been there? Would my friends call my bluff? Would everything I have seen on Street View for the past three days be close enough to the real thing? I am supposed to enjoy my Sunday. Go for a walk, play with my cat, and take a long, hot shower. 

Rome, May 5th, 2023 

Three months later, we are in Rome. The real Rome. After an 8-hour, exhausting Alitalia flight, we land at Fiumicino Airport. My first steps outside the terminal open a floodgate of memories. The smell of a big city transports me back to my early years, growing up in Paris: a mix of gas fumes, subway, and tobacco. 

Dazed and jet lagged, we take a taxi to our hotel in 'Trastevere'. The taxi driver, a young man from Libya, laughs and says: 'You are staying in the real Rome'.

'Trastevere' (Italian for 'across the Tiber River), is a part of Rome that originally was populated by the poor. Its small, winding, cobblestoned streets transports you to an era when Jewish immigrants peddled their merchandise on street corners. At the time, Rome was just as class-conscious as any modern metropolis. Basically, it was a ghetto.

Our top-floor unit has an enormous balcony that gives us a 360-degree view of the Eternal City. Shrieking seagulls fly overhead, and the occasional cowbird hops its way along the railing, looking at us intensely with its beady eyes. 

On the left, we can see the Vittoriano, with two large black chariots on its roof. Straight ahead, we see the Basilica di Santa Maria Maggiore, and on our right, in the hazy distance, is the world-famous St. Peter's Basilica. Am I still sitting at my desk in Boston, looking at Rome in Street View? 

We go out for coffee and breakfast. On the 'Viale di Trastevere’, traffic is dense and noisy. The cracked pavement is strewn with cigarette butts and bottle caps. Garbage dumpsters are filled to the brim. Well-fed seagulls perch on top of them, guarding their loot. Right away, you can tell that mighty Rome doesn’t know what to do with the amount of garbage it produces. 

It is said that the best way to see Rome is to walk, but I twisted my ankle just before we left Boston, so I hobble along, holding on to my husband’s arm for dear life. 

He is weighing his options on how to see Rome with an invalid wife. The 'hop on, hop off' double-deckers look attractive, but I am in no condition to hop, and taking a taxi everywhere would quickly land us in the poor house. So I suggest renting a wheelchair, but my husband looks at me with such disgust, that I suggest he go off and explore, while I street-view Rome from my spacious 8th-floor balcony. 

We try to be good tourists, but Rome is not for the faint of heart. You need strong armor to cope with the incredible amount of visitors. I read that 19,000 people a day visit the Colosseum. That is more than 2,000 people an hour! What exactly is the point?

We take a taxi to Palatine Hill, but cannot get in without a ticket. Somehow, taxis have evaporated in thin air, so we walk the whole way back across the Tiber River. Street-viewing Rome from my 8th-floor balcony seems like a very attractive alternative. 

Where is the Rome that I pictured in my head? The quiet streets of La Dolce Vita? The moonlit fountain where Anita Ekberg wades into, fully clothed? Where is the Rome of my dreams?

We keep our excursions local. The Basilica de Santa Maria de Trastevere, one of the oldest churches in the entire city, is within walking distance. Slowly we get used to the beer caps and the herd of humans and by the end of our stay, we finally begin to enjoy the city.

Montecatini Val di Cecina, May 12th 

We are in Tuscany. Our villa is completely hidden, even from the village. We can hear the shrieking of redheaded pheasants and the distant snorting of wild boar. The sun rises over the Tuscan hills and in the hazy distance, we see the Apennines.

Like many small towns in Tuscany, Montecatini was originally an Etruscan settlement. In fact, the entire region of Tuscany was home to the Etruscan civilization before the Romans conquered the area. They referred to the Etruscans as the Tusc or Etrusc, which is the origin of the word Toscana (Tuscany). 

The busy, crowded streets of Rome are now a faded memory. We gorge ourselves on the landscape and take short day trips to the surrounding towns: Volterra, Siena, and Colle Val di Elsa. It is tricky driving on narrow, curved roads that are clearly built for tractors. 

Read more...